By Pamela Anderson, PhD and Marcia Quackenbush, MS, MFT, MCHES (ETR)
What comes to mind when you hear the words “sex trafficking”?
If you’re like a lot of people, you might think of a sinister alley in a foreign country serving as the local red light district. Or you might imagine a woman who comes to the U.S. with hopes of a better life for herself and her family who is then forced to sell her body to pay debt bondage. Maybe you think of a young woman violently forced by a hated pimp to work the streets.
While all of these images do constitute forms of sex trafficking, they barely begin to tell the story. And as these disturbing pictures run through our minds, few of us add to our list the children and teens in our own communities. We aren’t likely to think of the students in our classrooms as they navigate the Internet or check into their social network sites.
Yes, It’s Real and It’s Here
Myths and misconceptions about human trafficking abound. The facts? Trafficking is both an international and a domestic problem. It affects young people as well as adults. It involves individuals of different sexual orientations and a range of sexual identities. There’s a good chance it’s affecting youth you know.
By addressing myths and clarifying the issues, educators have unique opportunities to make a difference. They can take practical steps to prevent trafficking and help young people protect themselves and their peers.
What is Sex Trafficking?
According to the federal Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA), human sex trafficking is the recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision or obtaining of a person for the purposes of a commercial sex act, in which the sex act is induced by force, fraud or coercion, or in which the person induced to perform such an act is a minor. When minors are involved in commercial sex, even in the absence of force, fraud or coercion, they are considered human trafficking victims.
Find definitions of “force,” “fraud” and “coercion” here.
What’s Online Got to Do With It?
Youth are recruited into sex trafficking in a range of ways—an older “friend” they meet at a party, a “boyfriend” who promises them a modeling or movie career, a family member or even, as some of ETR’s research has demonstrated, a same-age romantic partner. They may also be recruited by a Facebook connection, an Instagram follower or someone they meet in an online chat room.
Remember that 9 in 10 teens go online daily, and 1 in 4 say they are online “almost constantly.” Sexualized selfies and other images are frequently shared. Teens often comment on one another’s posts with flattering remarks that are sexualized in nature (“nice body,” “you’re hot,” “what a babe”).
As this has become more normative behavior, the recruitment and grooming behaviors of traffickers stand out less. Twenty years ago, a stranger asking a teen to pose for nude photos would have set off alarms for most youth. Today, it’s not unusual for someone a teen doesn’t know to praise a photo, encourage more explicit sharing and even suggest an in-person meeting.
One recent report found that while most of the trafficking victims they surveyed originally met their trafficker in person, younger victims recruited more recently were significantly more likely to have met their trafficker online. Websites, social networking sites and other online tools are being used not only to recruit youth, but also to facilitate trafficking and connect with customers.
What You Need to Know
Here are four things all educators need to know about online sex trafficking.
- Adolescent sex trafficking in the U.S. is real. It’s often difficult to see signs of adolescent sex trafficking. Reliable estimates of the number of youth involved do not exist. One study calculated that more than 244,000 children in the U.S. are at risk for trafficking. Over 80% of victims in confirmed sex trafficking cases in this country are U.S. citizens.
- It affects youth of all genders and can start at very early ages. Boys, girls, transgender and gender-fluid youth may all be recruited. Data on the average age at which children first become involved is difficult to pin down. Some reports suggest an average age of 13-16 for girls, but instances of children as young as 10 are not uncommon. There are also reports of children of 4 or 5 being initiated into trafficking.
- It’s probably affecting youth you know. You can’t tell by looking that someone has been involved in sex trafficking. Often, young people involved in trafficking don’t see themselves as victims. They may have great affection, even love, for the person doing the trafficking. They may feel they are making independent, mature decisions and affirming their own freedom and independence.
- Talking with youth about healthy relationships can make a difference. Sexual choices take place in the context of young people’s lives. Our organization, ETR, is doing research that looks at the role romantic relationships play in the choices teens make. This additional focus on relationships and situational context appears to enhance the ability to teach effective prevention skills to youth.
We believe this learning is also relevant to the prevention of human trafficking. Few youth who become involved in trafficking are abducted off the street by menacing strangers. Rather, they are engaged, courted and groomed by skilled individuals who read a young person’s need for attention, desire to be special or yearning for love.
Sometimes a trafficker offers the most powerful affirmation a young person has ever experienced—“You are beautiful exactly as you are.” This can be especially persuasive for youth who may have been marginalized in school settings, including gay and transgender youth, young people with learning differences or mental health issues, and survivors of trauma and sexual abuse.
What Educators Can Do
- Learn more
- Look over this excellent infographic from Polaris about online sex trafficking. If you work with older students, consider having them use this as a resource in a classroom lesson about human trafficking.
- Read the executive summary from the APA’s Report of the Task Force on Trafficking of Women and Girls. (Read the entire report if you have time.)
- Read ETR’s Best Practices Tip Sheet, 5 Things You Should Know About Adolescent Sex Trafficking.
- Check these national websites. You may be able to find statewide or local programs in your area that offer education and prevention resources.
- Talk with, not at, your students
- Help students learn about healthy relationships. (ETR’s HealthSmart, a comprehensive K-12 health curriculum, addresses healthy relationships in the unit on Emotional & Mental Health. Other curricula may address healthy relationships as a standalone topic, or within sexual health programs. NHTRC has a resource list for educators and students, including a Student Engagement Toolkit).
- Let students know that trafficking exists. Integrate the topic into classes addressing dating abuse or other types of violence. Share resources with students and encourage them to seek help for themselves or their friends if needed. (The NHTRC hotline is 1-888-373-7888, active 24/7.)
- Remember that the Internet and social media are not the enemy. These are vital sources of social engagement for most teens. Our goal is not to stop students from using technology. Rather, it is to help them build and practice the skills that allow them to use technology in empowering, self-affirming and productive ways.
What Are You Doing?
Have you addressed online sex trafficking with your students? We’d love to hear what you’ve done and what you’ve learned from your students.
Pamela Anderson, PhD, is a psychologist and Senior Research Associate at ETR with more than 10 years of experience conducting research in the area of sexual and reproductive health. Pam has considerable experience in designing, managing and implementing multi-site and multi-method evaluations in school settings featuring group-randomized designs. Her work focuses largely on the context of adolescent romantic relationships and understanding the impact of healthy and unhealthy behaviors on adolescents’ health and well-being. Pam’s work also includes a focus on the correlates and outcomes of unhealthy and violent relationships, including the commercial sexual exploitation of young people. She continues to be interested in the role technology plays in how adolescents in communicate with each other in relationships as well as how technology can be used in developing and adapting health promotion interventions for youth. Pam is also currently involved in an NIH-funded study to create and evaluate a blended learning pregnancy and HIV prevention intervention based on the content of the evidence-based program, Reducing the Risk.
Marcia Quackenbush, MS, MFT, MCHES, is Senior Editor in charge of ETR’s blog and newsletters. She is a licensed marriage and family therapist with over 25 years’ experience providing services and materials to schools and communities. Much of her clinical work has focused on adolescent and family issues, life transitions and coping with chronic and life-limiting medical conditions. She has authored over 35 published books, curricula and monographs, dozens of professional articles and over 100 health education pamphlets.